„[…] the goings-on at Atlantis are far from exciting. […] the cast is engaged in endless palaver, none of which could be described as exhilarating. The same can be said about the performances of the principals. […] The theory that Atlantis was submerged under an ocean seems more acceptable now that "Siren of Atlantis" is on view.“ – Rezension in der New York Times vom 22. August 1949, abgerufen am 27. März 2013.
