“Under normal circumstances, we wouldn’t believe a minute of Random Harvest, but the magic spell woven by the stars and by author James Hilton transforms the wildly incredible into the wholly credible.”Hal Erickson: Random Harvest bei AllMovie (englisch)
“Random Harvest is a first-rate film made from James Hilton’s second-rate novel of the same name. […] It is distinguished by 1) a moving love story, 2) the unveiling of Miss Garson’s interesting legs.” Vgl. Cinema: The New Pictures. In: Time, 28. Dezember 1942.
variety.com
“The film transcription of James Hilton’s novel Random Harvest […] achieves much more than average importance. […] Colman gives a fine performance […]. Greer Garson, more charming and seductive than ever, is an important mainstay of the picture. Essaying a highly sympathetic role, she overshadows Colman.” Vgl. Random Harvest. In: Variety, 1942.