Derek Armstrong: Kritik zu Summer Catch (Memento vom 2. Juli 2017 im Internet Archive) bei AllMovie (englisch) „[T]he characters are not all egregious stereotypes. […] But it all adds up to very little, because nothing feels challenging, funny, or memorable -- just tepid and safe. […] It's just vanilla – not the good kind of vanilla, but rather, the stale pint at the back of the freezer case, ignored and unseen.“
