The first Legislative Council also had four appointed members (Olva Georges, Benjamin Romney, Dr W.T. Joseph and A.T. Franklin (A.T. Franklin was replaced by Norwell Harrigan later in 1950. Norwell Harrigan was replaced by Arthur Caines in 1951. Arthur Caines was replaced by McWelling Todman QC in 1952. ("BVI election and information results 1950–2011"(PDF). BVI Deputy Governor's Office. p. 195. Archived from the original(PDF) on 7 April 2014.)
Particulars of the individual seats are not available for the 1957 general election. It possible to ascertain the list of members elected from the history of members appointed ("BVI election and information results 1950–2011"(PDF). BVI Deputy Governor's Office. pp. 47–63. Archived from the original(PDF) on 7 April 2014.), but not their seats. However it is reasonable to infer the representatives for the district seats on the basis that elected candidates most likely held the seats which they held in elections before and/or after the 1957 election. Waldo O'Neal is assumed to have been elected in the 5th District by process of elimination.
The first Legislative Council also had four appointed members (Olva Georges, Benjamin Romney, Dr W.T. Joseph and A.T. Franklin (A.T. Franklin was replaced by Norwell Harrigan later in 1950. Norwell Harrigan was replaced by Arthur Caines in 1951. Arthur Caines was replaced by McWelling Todman QC in 1952. ("BVI election and information results 1950–2011"(PDF). BVI Deputy Governor's Office. p. 195. Archived from the original(PDF) on 7 April 2014.)
Particulars of the individual seats are not available for the 1957 general election. It possible to ascertain the list of members elected from the history of members appointed ("BVI election and information results 1950–2011"(PDF). BVI Deputy Governor's Office. pp. 47–63. Archived from the original(PDF) on 7 April 2014.), but not their seats. However it is reasonable to infer the representatives for the district seats on the basis that elected candidates most likely held the seats which they held in elections before and/or after the 1957 election. Waldo O'Neal is assumed to have been elected in the 5th District by process of elimination.