Analysis of information sources in references of the Wikipedia article "Fred Rouhling" in English language version.
As other hard routes from that time put up by Fred, such as Hugh 9a, have been confirmed, he had a hard time understanding the downgrading. "I don't know but limestone cracks. Perhaps the holds became bigger. When Yuji Hirayama and Dai Koyamada came to try. They thought there was a very big difference between Akira and Hugh..
Critics should check out fredrouhling.com where most of his ascents are shown through videos. In fact, just by adding his First Ascents Fred would have been #3 in the 8a.nu All Time High Combined ranking.
Pete Ward is a Board Member of the American Alpine Club (AAC) as well as a member of the AAC Policy Committee.
In 1986, Antoine applied his "artistic" talents to his masterpiece La Rose et la Vampire (8b/5.13d), purposely chiseling the route to require an elegant, twisting, cross-body reach.
Not content with this the also managed to repeat Archipel, 8c+. This is the first of Rouhling harder routes to be repeated! They both confirmed the grade. Later they also worked Hugh and l´autre côté de la ciel, both 9a, without success. They agreed they are probably 9a.
1993 : First French 9a. Fred Rouhling - "Hugh" (Eaux-Claires)
[Translated] But according to him, Empreintes , instead of flirting with 9b, would be a notch less hard than the other two and would rather revolve around 8c+.
FA: Fred Nicole 1993. Repeats: François Nicole, Fred Rouhling, Cederic Bersandi, David Hohl, Josune Bereciartu, Iker Pou.
The video of Sébastien Bouin at Eaux Claires repeating Hugh the first 9a in France put up by Fred Rouhling in 1993.