François Ponchaud (Finnish Wikipedia)

Analysis of information sources in references of the Wikipedia article "François Ponchaud" in Finnish language version.

refsWebsite

Global rank Finnish rank

2archive.is

87^th place

65^th place

2web.archive.org

1^st place

1jim.com

low place

1ghosananda.org

low place

archive.is

1999 For A Change - Priest of many frontiers: Alan Channer meets Francois Ponchaud (1999), haettu 20.4.2008 ...Francois Ponchaud, a French priest who has spent most of his working life in Cambodia and the refugee camps on its border with Thailand. As author of Cambodia: Year Zero, he was the person who first alerted the world to the genocide perpetrated by the Pol Pot regime.
1999 For A Change - Priest of many frontiers: Alan Channer meets Francois Ponchaud (1999), haettu 20.4.2008

ghosananda.org

The controversial words from a French Catholic Priest in Cambodia, Francios Ponchaud about Somdech Preah Maha Ghosananda and Cambodian Buddhism with a responding to him from Bhikkhu Vodano Sophan, a Cambodian Buddhist Monk (Arkistoitu – Internet Archive) It is true that I voiced a somewhat discording tone in the concert of praises concerning the venerable Samdech Préah Moha Gosananda, called Moha Yao, the Cambodian Gandhi. I knew him in 1983 in his American residence of Hanover Street, Providence (RI). I voiced some reservations on his attitude at the time of our audience with Jean Paul II in Rome in 1985, but I leave the whole paternity to the author of the article for the qualifications, several times repeated, by which he qualifies this venerated monk, and of whom I respect the memory, like many Cambodians.

jim.com

The Khmer Rouge Canon 1975-1979: The Standard Total Academic View on Cambodia, haettu 20.4.2008 (Arkistoitu – Internet Archive) The Porter-Chomsky-Herman objections were numerous, but still Chomsky and Herman admitted that Ponchaud's book was "serious and worth reading" though full of discrepancies and unreliable refugee reports which were contradicted by other refugees (who, for instance, had said that they had walked across the country and seen no dead bodies). This was vindication of the Khmer Rouge-reports of having seen no evil nor heard any evil. The Porter-Chomsky-Herman logic in a nutshell: Refugees are run away because they are displeased, thus will exaggerate, especially over time, if not lie about "alleged atrocities" altogether.

web.archive.org

The Khmer Rouge Canon 1975-1979: The Standard Total Academic View on Cambodia, haettu 20.4.2008 (Arkistoitu – Internet Archive) The Porter-Chomsky-Herman objections were numerous, but still Chomsky and Herman admitted that Ponchaud's book was "serious and worth reading" though full of discrepancies and unreliable refugee reports which were contradicted by other refugees (who, for instance, had said that they had walked across the country and seen no dead bodies). This was vindication of the Khmer Rouge-reports of having seen no evil nor heard any evil. The Porter-Chomsky-Herman logic in a nutshell: Refugees are run away because they are displeased, thus will exaggerate, especially over time, if not lie about "alleged atrocities" altogether.
The controversial words from a French Catholic Priest in Cambodia, Francios Ponchaud about Somdech Preah Maha Ghosananda and Cambodian Buddhism with a responding to him from Bhikkhu Vodano Sophan, a Cambodian Buddhist Monk (Arkistoitu – Internet Archive) It is true that I voiced a somewhat discording tone in the concert of praises concerning the venerable Samdech Préah Moha Gosananda, called Moha Yao, the Cambodian Gandhi. I knew him in 1983 in his American residence of Hanover Street, Providence (RI). I voiced some reservations on his attitude at the time of our audience with Jean Paul II in Rome in 1985, but I leave the whole paternity to the author of the article for the qualifications, several times repeated, by which he qualifies this venerated monk, and of whom I respect the memory, like many Cambodians.