Donald A. Guarisco, « I Was Made for Lovin' You review on Allmusic », Allmusic, Rovi Corporation (consulté le ) "This careful balance of elements made "I Was Made For Lovin’ You" a surprisingly workable cross between hard rock and disco"
Scott Floman, « KISS » (consulté le ) "many older fans were further alienated by "I Was Made For Loving You," a smash disco hit that while catchy and danceable certainly wasn't very KISS-like."
