Rivadavia, Eduardo, « Overcome review », AllMusic (consulté le ) : « Overcome offers very dependable melodic metalcore in the spirit of All That Remains' albums past, without succumbing to outright stagnation. »
D. Taylor, Jason, « Suicide Notes and Butterfly Kisses review », AllMusic (consulté le ) : « Atreyu's debut album, Suicide Notes and Butterfly Kisses, is an invigorating foray into melodic metalcore in the vein of Darkest Hour, Poison the Well, and Eighteen Visions. »
Phil Freeman, « Alternative Press | Reviews | Bury Tomorrow - Portraits », Alternative Press, (consulté le ) : « If you're wondering whether they bring anything unique or unexpected to the table, the answer is no. Is Portraits a pleasurable enough melodic metalcore album while it's playing? Absolutely. »
